Learn Youtube Packaging from +60 Redesigns

My analysis :

Just added a polarizing element.

My analysis :

I showed in the most clear manner the video's topic.

My analysis :

I placed the culprit in action to provoke a strong reaction.

My analysis :

I used the game's universe to deliver the same message that the players would appreciate.

My analysis :

I illustrated the idea with a famous example.

My analysis :

A close up of the injured feet creates a stronger emotion.

My analysis :

I made a more realistic version.

My analysis :

I removed the text that repeated the title, and this allowed the focus to be on the empty seat.

My analysis :

I brought more emotion by linking the DVD with an actual movie from which a character always comes back.

My analysis :

I brought several cosmetic tweaks to stand out from the many similar thumbnails. I also made the title more clickbait.

My analysis :

-

My analysis :

I offered different approaches with stronger emotions

My analysis :

Original thumbnail was too clutered

My analysis :

Original angle was a little boring for this topic covered many times

My analysis :

Original was clutered, disharmonious and missed the most important point.

My analysis :

"stronger than concrete" did not make sense and "ice made of ice" neither.

My analysis :

I played on the fact that the review is obviously biased...

My analysis :

Original didn't show a clear link between money and google sheets. I suggested to use a sort of google sheet card in an actual wallet.

My analysis :

Original didn't really look like a challenge or that there was a stake.

My analysis :

The thumbnail was not matching the first frames of the inroduction and the title left some doubts. I cleared that up.

My analysis :

Original was very confusing.

My analysis :

The original thumbnail said "shouting out of the box". I used AI as well to get an image closer to thinking outside of the box.

My analysis :

The circular arrows gave a recycle turning movement, and the computer was the main focus instead of the app. Folowwing my advice the owner made 2 new designs.

My analysis :

Improved focus on key elements.

My analysis :

Added more contrast, made the text different from the title, added emotion through text.(French channel)

My analysis :

The original thumbnail had no real concept.

I'm showing distractions actually helping you focus.

My analysis :

The original thumbnail repeated the title. I put a different and shorter text for a stronger impact.

My analysis :

The original failed to convey clearly and simply the message that the same pilot lost once it joined Ferrari.

My analysis :

My creative take on this video

My analysis :

The original thumbnail although extremly visible lacked emotion and depth.

My analysis :

The original thumbnail said "ideas worth $1M" while the video is a challenge with a transformation or some action.

My analysis :

The original thumbnail was too soft so I brought emotions.

My analysis :

Originals did not convey the message clearly or missed the point.

My analysis :

Both original thumbnails were busy, disharmonious and unclear regarding the link between number of houses, their price and homelessness.

My analysis :

No original thumbnail was provided, I immediatly had the idea to contrast a scandalous dress with the puritan american Church. AI did a perfect job.

My analysis :

Originals look like advertisements and don't clearly present the video's content.

My analysis :

The original packaging seemed like a movie director's guide or a historic overview of silent fim while the video is about enticing people to try out silent movies.

My analysis :

I don't know who that chick is, I could mistake it for yet another video about AI tools. The game hub name and logo are generic, I don't know if it's a brand or the text of the thumbnail. Regarding the titles, I think they missed a strong angle.

My analysis :

The original packaging although attention grabing did not take advantage of the unique branding of Liquid Death.

My analysis :

The original thumbnail make waking up early look difficult and painful. There is also no high contrast. I made it look as easy as a toast.

My analysis :

The original was a ripoff of another video. The "mort" (death) word alone didn't make sense. I took the official logo and turned it against itself. (french channel)

My analysis :

Showing the actual link between watermelon and racism. And added emotion.

My analysis :

I gave a better representation of brain fog.

My analysis :

I made it more punchy.

My analysis :

The original image was not clear as to who the kid is and its relation to the company. Here I clearly showed the drama.

My analysis :

The original video was about the bad taste of a chocolate. The elements were not coherent with the message so I redesigned it by taking an ironical angle (a fake ad). Now the chocolate is so bad it will turn you into a zombie.

My analysis :

Example of thumbnail done with various AI generated assets.

Here a roblox gamer reacting.

My analysis :

Find a prompt that chatgpt normally refuses to execute, and make a thumbnail where it does execute it. Eventually you can add a hacker, possibly looking at the screen where the prompt is.

My analysis :

1&2) We see neither a panic attack nor a peaceful person. A peaceful person is more convincing than reaching a mountain top.

3) The calm part of the face looks anxious, there's emotion contamination.

My analysis :

Too small and I don't understand. So I would represent a close up view of typical saudi guy in front of a typical lab scientist in the desert. The scientist is holding sand in his hand or in small container, pointing at it and saying something like "this is gold" or "we found something" and the saudi is making a shock/amazed face. Possibly there's a tiny plant growing in that sand.

My analysis :

People will click out of curiosity, but curiosity is not enough for a good watchtime. A little somethign is missing for them to have a real expectation that will last the whole video. I would change the title to something like "Why millionaires don't wear Rolex" or the thumbnail text to "Swiss made" crossed out.

My analysis :

I thought it was coffee. If the seeds are the topic they should cover 30% of the image. You're putting too much emphasis on "was" which could indicate that he was right but not anymore. The background removal and glow are a little ugly, you would get a much better result with AI.

My analysis :

I would say the one with the plant in a pot. But in this one the bush one, the person is looking the wrong way (or I don't get it and this is what is actually weird). The curtain one looks like a horror cartoon. I would use the text as title, and use another shorter text saying "safe zone ->". The cartoon itself needs to be bigger.

My analysis :

Very low contrast and blueish tint on the portraits. Misleading ironic title. Since the 3 portrayed people are known for making lot of views I thought of turning them into criminals who robbed/hijacked youtube. (French channel)

My analysis :

Hmmm this is a case where A/B testing would be very useful. The first one is somewhat classic. We expect a title like "Are galaxies nothing but giant brains ?? science discovery". The second one is more mysterious. The brains look like evil sentinels from The Matrix. We expect a more personal opinion on the matter.

My analysis :

The design is orignal but overly complex for what a timeline really is.

My analysis :

The thumbnail is a still image from the footage,it is realistic but does not show action or danger.

My analysis :

It seems to be a working concept ! You could push it further and make it more realistic with a referee cutting/pulling open the ball and revealing what's inside. The electronic device should be a tiny chip in the ball skin rather than a full motherboard in the air.

My analysis :

The original idea is very banal, every thumbnail of every murder channel could use it. The title is absolutely not clickbait.

Simply watching the video gave me the unique keywords related to this case.

My analysis :

It doesn't look like an insane moment. The police cars could be confused with the safety cars. If you put that F1 on the city street then...

My analysis :

One of the items should be a different color for contrast. The car is ugly but cute kind of ugly so nobody will care much. So instead we should pick a car whose design people are going to fight over.